BAS and GST

Varying your PAYG instalments when income drops, and the penalty for getting it wrong

PAYG instalments are the ATO’s way of collecting your income tax through the year instead of in one lump after your return. The ATO works out your instalments from your last return, which is fine when this year looks like last year. When it does not, because you lost a big client, took time off, or moved to a part-time job, the instalments can be far more than the tax you will end up owing. You are allowed to vary them. This guide explains how, when, and how to avoid the interest charge that applies if you vary too low.

Updated 15 November 2026. General information only, not tax advice.

A quick refresher on instalments

You are usually put into PAYG instalments once your business and investment income on your last return passes a threshold and the tax on it is above a set amount. Most sole traders pay quarterly, on the same activity statement as their GST. You are either given an instalment amount (option 1) or an instalment rate to apply to your actual income each quarter (option 2). See PAYG instalments explained.

When varying makes sense

  • Your income has fallen significantly this year.
  • You have taken on a salaried role and tax is now withheld from your wages.
  • You have large new deductions, such as a big equipment purchase.
  • You are closing the business. See closing a sole trader business.

If income has gone up, you are not required to vary upwards, but paying more now avoids a large bill when you lodge. The rate method adjusts automatically because it applies to what you actually earn.

How to vary

You vary on the activity statement or instalment notice for the quarter, through ATO online services, a registered agent, or by phone. You need to do it by the due date of the instalment you want to change.

  • Varying the amount (option 1). Estimate your total tax for the year, subtract instalments already paid, and spread the rest over the remaining quarters. Enter the varied amount and a reason code.
  • Varying the rate (option 2). Estimate your tax for the year, divide by your estimated instalment income, and enter the new rate with a reason code.

The activity statement asks for the estimated tax for the year and the reason. Keep your working.

The variation penalty

Varying is your estimate, so the ATO checks it against what actually happens. If the instalments you paid after varying are less than 85% of a benchmark based on your actual tax for the year, the ATO may charge the general interest charge on the difference. It may also apply a penalty in some cases. The interest is calculated from each instalment due date to the date your return is due.

The practical rule is to be realistic rather than optimistic, and to vary again if things improve during the year.

Claiming back what you have already paid

If you vary partway through the year and your earlier instalments already exceed what you now expect to owe, you can claim a credit for some of the instalments already paid on a later activity statement, with the reason. Any remaining overpayment comes back when you lodge your tax return, because instalments are credited against the tax assessed.

Doing the estimate well

Start with your income year to date, add a realistic projection for the remaining months, subtract expected deductions, and apply the resident tax rates and Medicare levy. Include tax withheld from any wages, since that also counts towards your bill. Our sole trader tax rates guide and the sole trader tax calculator help with the arithmetic. Revisit the estimate each quarter.

How FlowFi helps

FlowFi’s Tax Pot uses your actual transactions for the year to estimate what to set aside, which is a useful starting point for a variation estimate. It does not lodge variations; you enter the new amount or rate on your activity statement yourself.

Email me the quarterly BAS checklist

The checklist now, then a few short notes on getting your BAS done. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Frequently asked questions

Can I vary my PAYG instalments to zero?

Yes, if you expect no tax on business and investment income for the year. If you end up owing more than the benchmark, the general interest charge can apply.

How many times can I vary in a year?

You can vary as often as your circumstances change, each time on or before the due date of the instalment you are varying.

Do I lose the money if I overpay instalments?

No. Instalments are credits against your tax. Any excess is refunded or offset against other debts when your return is assessed.

General information only, not tax advice. Check your own situation with a registered tax agent or the ATO.

Know your tax number before you vary

Upload your statements and FlowFi’s Tax Pot estimates the tax on this year’s actual income, so your variation starts from real figures.

Start 7-day free trial

7 days free. Card needed to start, nothing charged for 7 days, cancel anytime. Then $29 a month or $290 a year.

Still comparing tools? See the best accounting software for sole traders in Australia, compared side by side.

Related guides